Hotels in Fishers Island

Fishers Island: A Hidden Sanctuary of Serenity and Adventure

Nestled off the coast of Connecticut, Fishers Island, New York, is a hidden gem that exudes tranquil charm. This idyllic destination is perfect for those seeking a serene escape, boasting pristine beaches, lush landscapes, and captivating coastal views. Explore the island’s rich maritime history at the Fishers Island Museum, or indulge in fresh seafood at local eateries. With its secluded atmosphere, scenic bike paths, and stunning sunsets, Fishers Island offers a romantic retreat for couples and a peaceful haven for nature lovers. Unwind and reconnect with the beauty of the outdoors on this enchanting, off-the-beaten-path paradise.

Discover great hotels in Fishers Island

Fishers Island offers a range of accommodations, from charming inns to upscale hotels, catering to various budgets. Prices can vary widely depending on the season and type of lodging. Enjoy beautiful views, cozy atmospheres, and easy access to the island’s natural beauty while exploring your options. Here are some of our travelers' favorite hotels in Fishers Island:

1. Hilltop Express InnOpens in a new window: This inviting 2.5-star motel offers a comfortable stay with essential amenities like Television and Cable TV. The property is conveniently located near various attractions, ensuring a fulfilling experience. Travelers appreciate the lively atmosphere and the range of entertainment options in the vicinity, making it an excellent choice for those looking to explore and unwind.
2. Harbor View LandingOpens in a new window: Harbor View Landing is a dynamic 2.5-star guesthouse that caters to adventurous travelers seeking unique experiences. With exciting adventure sports available, including onsite kayaking and fishing, this property is an ideal retreat for those who thrive on outdoor activities. Guests commend the thrilling recreational options nearby, enhancing the overall adventure vacation experience.
3. Hampton Inn GrotonOpens in a new window: Offering a 2.5-star welcoming environment, Hampton Inn Groton is an exceptional choice for leisure travelers seeking a pet-friendly getaway. This hotel not only accommodates pets but also features thoughtful amenities that enhance comfort and convenience. The property is celebrated for its inclusive atmosphere and distinctive offerings, creating a delightful experience for those traveling with their furry companions.

Top locations to stay in Fishers Island

Some great areas to stay in when visiting Fishers Island, New York, are Mystic, Groton, and Stonington. Mystic offers a charming port atmosphere and an aquarium, Groton is known for its casino and museums, while Stonington is perfect for family-friendly activities. For first-time visitors, Mystic is best suited due to its unique attractions and vibrant ambiance.

1. MysticOpens in a new window: Mystic is a charming coastal village known for its picturesque harbor and maritime heritage. It’s a fantastic place to stay if you love exploring quaint shops and local boutiques. Don’t miss the Mystic Seaport Museum, where you can step back in time and experience life as it was in a historic whaling town. The Mystic Aquarium is a must-see, featuring engaging exhibits and marine life, including playful sea lions. With a laid-back atmosphere and beautiful scenery, Mystic is perfect for a relaxing getaway while still offering plenty of cultural experiences.
2. GrotonOpens in a new window: Groton offers a unique blend of history and nature, making it a great location for those looking to explore. Visit the historic Fort Griswold State Park for a glimpse into the past, or enjoy the scenic beauty of the nearby bluff and beaches. Groton is also home to some delightful shopping spots and local markets, providing a taste of the local culture. With easy access to the waterfront, you can enjoy outdoor activities like walking along the shore or simply taking in the views.
3. StoningtonOpens in a new window: Stonington is a quaint town that boasts beautiful waterfront views and a rich maritime history. It’s an ideal spot for travelers seeking a peaceful retreat with charming streets lined with historic homes. The Stonington Vineyards offers a relaxing experience for wine enthusiasts, while the local beaches provide a perfect place to unwind. The town's cultural scene is vibrant, with art galleries and events showcasing local talent. Stonington’s small-town charm and scenic landscapes make it a delightful destination for those looking to escape the hustle and bustle.

Things to do in Fishers Island

Fishers Island is a hidden gem for travelers seeking a mix of relaxation and excitement. Enjoy scenic hiking trails, explore the crystal-clear waters through boating and diving, or unwind at charming shops filled with local treasures. This tranquil escape promises unforgettable moments in a stunning coastal setting.

• Mystic SeaportOpens in a new window – Step into the rich maritime heritage at Mystic Seaport, where you can explore historic ships, engage with knowledgeable staff, and learn about the art of shipbuilding. Don't miss the chance to wander through the charming village that brings the seafaring past to life.
• Naval Submarine Base New LondonOpens in a new window – Although primarily a military installation, the Naval Submarine Base offers a glimpse into naval history. Nearby, you'll find informative displays and exhibits that shed light on the importance of submarines in maritime defense.
• Montauk PointOpens in a new window – Visit the iconic Montauk Point, a historic lighthouse that stands proudly along the rugged coastline. Climb up for breathtaking views of the Atlantic Ocean and capture stunning photos of the surrounding landscapes.
• Montauk Point LighthouseOpens in a new window – Adjacent to Montauk PointOpens in a new window, the Montauk Point Lighthouse is a must-see. This historic structure not only guides sailors but also offers visitors a chance to learn about its storied past through informative tours.
• Misquamicut State BeachOpens in a new window – Relax and soak up the sun at Misquamicut State Beach, where soft sands meet gentle waves. Enjoy beachcombing, swimming, or simply lounging under the sun, making it a great spot for families and sun-seekers alike.

5 tips for savvy savings when booking a hotel in Fishers Island

1. Book for the cheapest times: The most budget-friendly time to visit Fishers Island is from January to March, when hotel prices are generally lower. For a great value for money experience, staying for at least 2 to 3 days is recommended to fully explore the island's key landmarks, historical sites, and cultural attractions. During your visit, you can enjoy family-friendly activities, shopping, and dining options that highlight the local history and community. Keep in mind that prices may drop during this period, making it an ideal time for those traveling on a budget.
2. Look for last-minute deals on Hotels.com: To find last-minute deals for Fishers Island, you may start by exploring the DealsOpens in a new window or Last-Minute DealsOpens in a new window sections on Hotels.com, where you could find discounted hotel rates as your travel date approaches. Additionally, consider enabling email alerts or push notifications to stay informed about flash sales and special promotions, helping you to save. The Smart ShoppingOpens in a new window tool available via the app allows you to compare hotel prices and amenities, so if rooms become available or prices drop, you’re more likely to see these updates first-hand and seize the opportunity for a last-minute getaway.
3. Be flexible with dates: Prices can fluctuate depending on factors like the hotel's location, star rating, and the time of year. Being flexible with your travel dates may help you save on your stay at a Fishers Island hotel. If you're in search of something different, boutique hotels often provide a more personalized experience and can sometimes offer better value. When you book through Hotels.com, we’ll inform you if the price for your chosen dates is above or below the average. If the price is on the higher side, we’ll recommend more budget-friendly dates, which could help you find a better deal.
4. Consider your location: Choosing accommodations near major attractions or city centers can offer convenience, but it usually tends to come with higher prices. For more affordable options, think about staying in neighborhoods that are a bit farther out, allowing you to balance cost with accessibility to the sites you want to visit. You might also look into independent hotels that are located further away, as they can often provide a more authentic experience while being more likely to be budget-friendly.
5. Become a Member: Join our membership program for free and unlock exclusive benefits for your next stay in Fishers Island! Enjoy savings on over 100,000 hotels worldwide with special member prices. As you engage with our program, you'll have the opportunity to advance through the tiers and gain access to fantastic perks, including complimentary room upgrades when available and discounts on food and beverages at select VIP Access properties. Don't miss out on a more rewarding travel experience—become a member today!

Best time to go to Fishers Island

Fishers Island experiences its lowest average temperature in January, at 32.0°F (0.0°C), while July is the hottest month, with an average temperature of 73.0°F (22.8°C). October are usually the wettest months. June to August are the peak travel months in Fishers Island, attracting a higher number of tourists. During this peak period, the weather is mostly sunny, accompanied by light rainfall. On the other hand, January, November, and December tend to be quieter times to visit, marked by light rainfall and mostly sunny conditions.